Skip to content
Oatmeal Sandwich Cookies, Pack of 4 (13oz)
Regular price $14.99
Sale Sold out
- +

They may look similar to the ones in the supermarket, but don't be fooled! These rich and flavorful treats are made with our exclusive recipe. Two soft and chewy cookies are sandwiched together with a thick layer of our original icing. 13oz total weight. 

  • 5 stars: 184 (73%)
  • 4 stars: 25 (10%)
  • 3 stars: 15 (6%)
  • 2 stars: 12 (5%)
  • 1 star: 15 (6%)
D
Debora Poythress

The oatmeal sandwich cookies are very tasty!
I was disappointed however to see that they contain a bioengineered product.
I will not be buying these again.
Your thin cookies don’t have fake products so why would you do that on the oatmeal sandwich cookies.

M
Msdogdame

What I didn’t care for was the icing moisture got absorbed so much by the cookie that it was just the icing and the cookie were crumbly and messy. It was not enjoyable at all, and it was way too much icing, maybe less icing would lessen the absorption and crumbling effect

D
Deekats

This is like if oatmeal cookies made by your granny (with raisins in them the way you like but nobody else does) meets oatmeal cream pies from the gas station that you know you love even though they're nutritionally garbage. Oh and I'm allergic to cinnamon, I know it's sad, and these are one of the rare oatmeal items that I can actually have without worrying. I'm going to die. Freaking fababulous

D
Donnelle A.

The best...I love to warm them...have with coffee !!!

J
Jerry
I would buy this again and recommend you give one a try !

The best oatmeal cream cookie I've ever tasted. I can only eat a half one at a time.. Warm a few seconds and pour the coffee!

M
Mily D
Awesome! AWESOME! Awesome!!

These are hands down the BEST oatmeal sandwich cookies I have EVER had. My husband's name is Dewey so a friend sent him a variety box for a gift. Everything was very good. But the oatmeal sandwich cookies were to die for!!! I'm addicted!!

A
Anonymous

The filling is too sweet! I had to separate the cookies, which are good, and scrape it off.

K
Karen Laibach

liked

V
Vance

These are the best cookies I have ever had. I order them all the way from Texas as soon as I run out. Dewey’s has a special place in my heart!

T
Terry Robertson

The Oatmeal Sandwich Cookies and the Triple Ginger cookies are delicious!
We have been enjoying Dewey's since the early 50s.
Love the Moravian bun with a cup of coffee.

D
Don Montgomery

Nobody can top Dewey's oatmeal cake...NO NO NO!! Dewey's r 💯 delicious 😋

v
valinda jacobs

Remember oatmeal cream cakes when you were growing up? How smooth, tender, and melt away it was? Now put them on steroids, grab a cup of coffee or glass of milk, sit back and enjoy. Delicious!!

c
charles huffmAN

Too much cream in the middle. All you coudl taste was overly sweet cream. That Oatmeal cooking as Oatmeal in the name for a reason. You could not taste the oatmeal. I wanted to taste chewy oatmeal. That flavor was not present in that cookie. If you were blind folded I do not think you would know it was an Oatmeal cooking.

M
Margaret Anthony

Way too sweet for my taste. I was unable to eat it.

J
Jennifer Tavizon

Hello. I’m sad to say these oatmeal sandwich cookies are terrible. The cookies itself was soft, and had nice flavor. The inside icing was horrible. It’s thin and the icing is crystallized. So it’s crunchy-ish and just off putting. I was so hopeful that these would be amazing as they were pricey for what they were.

D
Diane

All is good.

T
Terry Garza

Arrived perfectly packaged, fresh and delicious. Glad they were available, they are so good they are usually sold out. These cookies are so big I cut them in four and eat over a couple days. These cookies are a great complement to vanilla almond tea.

P
Patsy Ingram

The oatmeal cookie and filling was dry. If you took a bite the entire thing crumbled. The taste was fine, but you couldn’t eat it even as a cookie. It was a disaster and a mess. I would not be ordering this again or would I recommend it?

L
Lucinda Hemmick

Sorry, but these are strangely bad for your brand. The oatmeal is too mushy and the filling is too stiff and sweet. Recommend a more toasted oatmeal and a smooth, creamy filling.

K
Kathleen Barss

Very yummy oatmeal cookies 😊

P
P. H. Carter

these were a Father's Day gift & well received.

S
Suzanne Z.

Delicious but very rich and filling. A meal in itself.

s
stephanie roeser

.

M
Michael

Everything they are so good!!!

J
John W.

They are also great

F
Francisca

They are so yummy!

M
Michael

Absolutely amazing,so glad we bought them, will definitely buy again.

B
Bilal S.

These were dry and the icing tasted stale! I will never buy these again!

R
Robin

The cookie is really good, the filling is really sweet. I personally dont care for overly sweet anything but these cookies are HUGE and the oatmeal cookie is excellent! Very good!

M
Missy W.

The ones in this order were not in a box. They seem old and the cream was dry and crumble. I have them previously in December that were much better. Very disappointed this time.