Skip to content
Key Lime Cookies, 9oz
Regular price $7.49 Sale price $5.83
Sale Sold out
- +

Thin cookie. Big flavor. Our newest cookie captures the flavor of key limes perfectly!

  • We bake with cold-pressed Key Lime oil and a dash of pure cane sugar to strike a perfect balance of sweet and tart
  • 100% real ingredients: no artificial flavors, no preservatives and no synthetic colors
  • 8 cookies = 120 calories!  10g sugar and 19g carbs per 8-cookie serving. Click to view full nutrition info. 
  • 9-ounce box contains about 68 cookies
  • Made in our hometown bakery in Winston-Salem, NC since 1930 - click here to learn more about the history of our Moravian Cookies
  • 5 stars: 146 (83%)
  • 4 stars: 18 (10%)
  • 3 stars: 7 (4%)
  • 2 stars: 3 (2%)
  • 1 star: 2 (1%)
E
Eric G.

Light, summer time flavor! We make little ice cream sandwiches!

F
Frank Leone

Taste just like Florida

A
Anonymous

Needs more Lime flavor

L
Lori Stokes

My favorite flavor (so far)!

A
Anonymous

These are amazing

K
Kathleen Schlingloff

These cookies were the best cookies. I definitely will buy them again.

L
Linda Roemisch

I love the taste of key limes these were pretty close to what I expected. I would love a stronger key lime taste in these. Shipping was great packed well no breakage.

j
jesse rhyne

Good flavor.

J
Jessica

I personally didnt like the flavor

F
Faye Miller

Unusual flavor and perfect for summer entertaining.

S
Sharon H.

Yummy. Just the right amount of lime!

T
Teresa G.

Awesome

L
Lori Uuro

.

C
Customer

Delicious!

B
Brenda F.

They were good but of the four I have tried it has been my least favorite. I ordered the Key Lime but even Key Lime pie isn’t a favorite.

L
Lisa M.

Delicious!

P
Patricia H.

Yummy

M
Michael A.

My clients loved them.

E
Eugene G.

Great

M
Mary Ann C.

Delightful

D
DINAH HOLLIFIELD

.

M
Martha H.

Wonderful taste

C
Cathy Landgren

.

M
Mary-Jo W.

Love these !

D
Donald P.

The Key Lime cookies are a new BEST for Dewy’s. They have moved into first place for my future ordering!

E
Emily S.

I legit squealed when I saw that Dewey's Bakery makes Key Lime cookies. Like I said in other reviews, this is already my favorite cookie company, but when I saw that they made Key Lime cookies? I had to try them. And wow, they don't disappoint! They somehow pack a whole lotta key lime flavor into these little tiny cookies!

M
Marsha Y.

Very tasty, my husband seemed to like them, and he does not really like different types of cookies. The lime was just right for flavoring, although I would grab them as my go to flavor.

D
Deborah B.

Delicious! Also, thought about using them as the crust for a key lime pie!

B
Beth H.

Delicious!!!! L8ve anything Key Lime and these don't disappoint!

G
G G.

Refreshing, lately the lime flavor seems to have been enhanced (good)

n
nicole r.

My son’s favorite cookies

M
Milers

Delicious, and very light and crispy!

L
Linda M.

Cookies are a hit. Just a hint of key lime puts them on a par with your lemon cookies. Those are my faves.

K
Kathleen M.

I love the key lime cookies! The flavor is just right! Low in calories, and at a great price.

T
Terri A.

Amazing cookies, but I would like a stronger lime flavor. I’ll still buy them, though! 😂